Paper Economy - A US Real Estate Bubble Blog

Monday, January 21, 2008

The Almost Daily 2¢ - Twin Peaks?

Following up on a prior post, take a look at the trend and most recent state of the S&P 500 index and compare it to the last major bear market conditions that followed the dot-com bust.

There is a host of very interesting technical similarities (which are noted below) that may indicate that we have entered or are just about to enter another bear market where on average the S&P 500 index retraces 20 – 30% from its prior peak.

It’s important to keep in mind that, at best, a bear market can be viewed as a transition into an period where there is a prolonged bias to sell into strength resulting in a successive series of lower highs yielding a clear downward trend.

At worst, there are periods (days or weeks) where particular stocks and the index as a whole will crash hard.

Study the following image (click for very large and clear version) of the S&P 500 index from 1995 to today then read below for the technical blow by blow.

Notice that I’ve added both the “effective” federal funds rate (light gray line) and an overlay indicating the period of the last recession.

As you can see, entering the last bear market, the Fed cut rate significantly taking it from 6.5% at the start of the bear market to 1.25% in the trough.

It’s important to note that although the Federal Reserve’s response was dramatic, the market still resulted in an over 48% decline.



THEN (1998 – 2000 Top)

  • A. October 1998 – S&P 500 gives early warning sign by crossing its 400 day simple moving average (SMA). Notice also that the 50 day SMA breached the 200 day SMA.
  • B. October 1999 – S&P 500 gives a second signal by crossing its 200 day SMA after a solid twelve month expansion. 50 day SMA touches the 200 day SMA.
  • C. Three prominent but decelerating peaks set up the top.
  • D. Between second and third (last) peak S&P 500 index breaches 200 day SMA. After the final peak S&P 500 index breaches the 400 day SMA.
  • E. 50 day SMA heads down fast and crosses the 200 day SMA.
  • F. 50 day SMA crosses 400 day SMA.
  • G. 200 day SMA crosses 400 day SMA.

NOW (Today’s Top?)

  • A. June 2006 – S&P 500 gives early warning sign by crossing its 400 day SMA. Notice also that the 50 day SMA breached the 200 day SMA.
  • B. March 2007 – S&P 500 gives a second signal by falling near its 200 day SMA after a solid nine month expansion. 50 day SMA similarly depressed.
  • C. Three prominent but decelerating peaks set up the top.
  • D. Between second and third (last) peak S&P 500 index breaches 200 day SMA. After the final peak S&P 500 index breaches the 400 day SMA.
  • E. 50 day SMA heads down fast and crosses the 200 day SMA.
  • F. TBD
  • G. TBD
Needless to say then next few weeks will be white-knuckle time…

Labels: , , ,

Copyright © 2009
PaperEconomy Blog - www.papereconomy.com
All Rights Reserved

Disclaimer

5 Comments:

  • White-knuckle time, or brown-trouser time?

    I particularly like the alphabetical references you included on the graph - it makes it a bit easier to visualize what's going on through all of the jagged peaks and valleys when you call it out like that.

    But "negative" was misspelled at the top of the graph.

    By Blogger A Unique Alias, at 2:07 PM  

  • (err - second graph, that is)

    By Blogger A Unique Alias, at 2:08 PM  

  • http://realestate.msn.com/selling/Article2.aspx?cp-documentid=2856666>1=10833

    Check out this MSN post on "the right words + the right price makes a sale.". Huh? I bet its more the right price than specific words. What this article fails to state is that there is some reality when you go and visit the home, you don't want to waste people's time right? The homes that use the word Beautiful and sell faster maybe because they really were beautiful, not because they used that word. Duh. This seems all part of the reality denial that is going on...
    People dont want to get around to the fact that home prices in Boston are around 50-80% too high. This is all deck chairs on the titanic, no?

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:04 PM  

  • Sold, Clearly you are able to put much more time into thinking about this than I can. It's inevitable that we are going into a recession - even the politicians have acknowledged this - and we know the fed is unable to stop this slide - at best they can help speed the recovery a bit (and hopefully not trigger another bubble in the process). My question to you is, when do you think the S+P will start recovering - or at least what signals should I look for to move out of cash and into the market again? I don't have time or the savvy to short the market but going long at this point seems foolish. Thanks. BTW, thanks for everything you do on this site.

    By Anonymous Verjeep, at 3:22 PM  

  • AUA,

    Thanks! I agree... Tomorrow will be an interesting trading day to say the least.

    The tech analysis is not a crystal ball but things don't look good...

    Ill keep updating the chart over the next few weeks to see if the bear market continues to materialize.

    anon,

    Good find... it seems similar to the "staging" phenomena.

    I'm sure a well worded ad can't hurt the sale but the housing markets are fundamentally broken and no amount of fluffy phrasing will fix that.

    You are right.. these are all manifestations of the desperate nature of current sellers... but nothing is more infuriating to a potential buyer than showing up at the open house and realizing that things like sq. footage has been overstated...

    Buyers in this market are able to be choosy and over blowing a homes features will just cause it to be immediately rejected.

    Verjeep,

    Thank for the good words!

    On the fate of the S&P 500 its pretty hard to say.

    The one thing you can consider is that the average decline in a recessionary bear market is 20-30% for the S&P 500 but the last peak to trough (after the dot-com bubble) was 48%.

    Another key thing to consider is that many of the S&P 500's components have already declined substantially (some 40% etc.) and they may be an early indication of the decline that will be seen in the index as a whole.

    By Blogger SoldAtTheTop, at 5:16 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home


 
Top Real Estate Blogs Top Real Estate Blogs Blogarama - The Blog Directory Check Google Page Rank